Skip to main content
FeaturedGeneral

The Scoop on Coffee and Alternatives

Healthy Coffee Substitutes: 11 Better-For-You Coffee Alternatives (Plus Healthier Ways To Keep Your Cup)

If you drink coffee, you’re in very good company. According to the National Coffee Association’s National Coffee Data Trends, about two-thirds of American adults drink coffee each day (66%), and the average coffee drinker has around 3 cups per day. There’s a reason coffee has earned that kind of loyalty: for many people, it genuinely does come with some perks.  This article is the real scoop on coffee and coffee alternatives.

Coffee Can Be Healthy (In The Right Dose)

Some research links moderate coffee intake to a lower risk of several major health issues. Harvard School of Public Health points out that drinking roughly 2 to 5 cups per day makes it less likely that you’ll develop conditions like type 2 diabetes, heart disease, and certain liver conditions. Coffee also has a lot of bioactive compounds, like antioxidants.

So, yes, coffee can fit into a healthy lifestyle. However, that doesn’t mean it’s the case for everyone.

When Coffee Isn’t Your Friend

Even if coffee has potential benefits, your body’s response matters more than the headlines. If coffee leaves you feeling wired, anxious, nauseated, or burning with heartburn by 10 a.m., that “healthy habit” may not be so helpful.

Here are a few common reasons you might want to cut back or switch it up.

You’re Sensitive To Caffeine

Caffeine affects people differently. For most adults, the FDA recommends 400 mg of caffeine per day as an amount “not generally associated with negative effects”, which translates to roughly two to three 12-ounce coffees, depending on how strong you make them. However, if you’re sensitive to caffeine, even that much can mean dealing with

  • Jitters or shakiness
  • Racing heart
  • Anxiety
  • Digestive upset
  • Poor sleep (even if you drink it early)

Of those, that last one matters more than you might think. If coffee is sabotaging your nights, it can affect energy, mood, focus, and even how hungry you are.

Coffee Can Aggravate Heartburn Or Reflux For Some People

Let’s talk about the question so many coffee lovers have asked at some point: Does coffee’s acidity give you reflux?

The short version: According to the Mayo Clinic, caffeinated coffee can make reflux symptoms worse for some people, even though triggers vary a lot from person to person.

There’s also other research showing that caffeine can affect stomach acid secretion and lower esophageal sphincter pressure (the “valve” that helps keep stomach contents where they belong).

That said, reflux triggers aren’t one-size-fits-all. Some people can drink coffee with zero issues. Others feel the burn halfway through the mug. If you suspect coffee is a culprit, a simple test helps: swap to a gentler alternative for a couple of weeks and see what changes.

You’re Pregnant Or Trying To Be

If pregnancy is part of your life right now, it’s worth knowing that ACOG recommends that you cut back caffeine to less than 200 mg per day.

Healthy Coffee Substitutes (Caffeinated And Caffeine-Free)

If you want the comfort of a warm mug without the side effects, you’ve got options.

1) Matcha

If you still want caffeine and focus, matcha might be the better choice. It’s still a stimulant, but it tends to feel steadier than coffee for some people.

2) Green Tea Or Black Tea

Tea is a classic swap. It has less caffeine than coffee, but it’s still familiar and satisfying. If you’re easing down slowly, this is a good choice.

3) Yerba Mate

Yerba mate has a loyal following because it can feel energizing without the “coffee crash.” (If you’re caffeine-sensitive, start small.)

4) Chicory “Coffee”

If what you really love is the taste of coffee, chicory root is a great choice. It’s naturally caffeine-free, roasty, and often used in coffee blends.

5) Dandelion Root Tea (Roasted)

This is another caffeine-free, earthy option with a dark, toasty flavor, which pairs especially well with a splash of milk.

6) Rooibos “Espresso”

Rooibos is naturally caffeine-free and can be brewed strong. It won’t taste exactly like coffee, but it makes a surprisingly satisfying latte-style drink.

7) Mushroom Coffee (Or Mushroom “Tea” Blends)

Some blends replace part (or all) of the coffee with functional mushrooms. If you like the idea, make sure to check the labels. Many still contain caffeine, and not all contain the same mushrooms/mushroom concentration.

8) Golden Milk

Golden milk is just warm milk (or an alternative like oat or cashew milk) with turmeric, cinnamon, and ginger.

9) Cacao (Hot Cocoa, But Make It Grown-Up)

Pure cacao has a deeper, less sugary taste than hot chocolate mixes, and it can feel like a treat without all the calories of dessert.

10) Decaf Coffee

Decaf still has trace caffeine, but it can be a great middle ground if you love the flavor. If reflux is your issue, some people tolerate decaf better while others don’t. Try it, but listen to your body.

11) Cold Brew (If Acid Is The Issue)

If you’re not ready to quit coffee, cold brew is usually less acidic and may be gentler for some people (though it can still contain a lot of caffeine).

Love Coffee No Matter The Acid? Make Your Cup Healthier

Maybe you don’t want to replace coffee. That’s fair. Here are a few add-ins and tweaks that can help make that morning cup of joe healthier.

Choose What You Add Carefully

If your daily coffee includes a lot of sugar and flavored syrups, “coffee” might not be the issue. It might be everything else in the cup.

Try:

  • Cinnamon
  • Unsweetened cocoa or cacao
  • A splash of real vanilla
  • Protein-friendly add-ins like collagen

Eat Something With Your Coffee

Coffee on an empty stomach can feel like a punch in the gut for some people, especially if you’re prone to reflux or nausea. Pair it with something simple, like yogurt, eggs, oatmeal, or a handful of nuts.

Try A “Half-Caff” Transition

If quitting cold turkey sounds miserable, you can taper:

  • Week 1: 75% regular/25% decaf
  • Week 2: 50/50
  • Week 3: 25% regular/75% decaf

Here’s to a Healthier Pick-Me-Up

Coffee can absolutely be part of a healthy routine, at least until it isn’t. If you’re dealing with reflux, anxiety, shaky energy, or poor sleep, switching to a healthier coffee substitute can be one of the simplest “small changes” you can make.

Pick one alternative that sounds enjoyable, commit to it for a week, and pay attention to what changes for you (energy, digestion, mood, sleep, etc.). Your body will tell you what it prefers.